Newcomerstown Home Search

Newcomerstown Homes for Sale

Search the newest Newcomerstown homes for sale. This information is updated daily so be sure to check back often! Search the complete inventory of Newcomerstown real estate by price, community features, architectural style, and more using the detailed ADVANCED SEARCH option.

If you would like personalized assistance or if a property interests you, please contact us. We are happy to assist you in finding the perfect home, scheduling a private showing, answering financial questions, or learning more about Newcomerstown real estate.

Your Newcomerstown Real Estate Experts

Buying or selling property can be very stressful. Let us help make this a smooth transaction. Using the latest technology, we help you understand the Newcomerstown real estate market, giving you a competitive advantage. For a FREE consultation regarding your real estate needs, please contact us today.

Considering selling your home? Receive a FREE INSTANT HOME VALUE for any Ohio address.

Featured Areas / Newcomerstown

Refine Your Search

 

Map Search

Explore Newcomerstown real estate for sale by map.

 

Market Report

View active and sold Newcomerstown listings.

Homes For Sale in Newcomerstown

492 S River Street, Newcomerstown
$275,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5255450 MLS
Spacious Family Home in the Heart of Newcomerstown! Looking for room for the whole family? This 3-bedroom home features 1 full custom bathroom and 2 half baths, with beautiful details throughout! The kitchen showcases eye-catching tile work and plenty of space for cooking, baking, and gathering. Just off the kitchen, you'll find a convenient office/den space, perfect for working from home, studying, or creating your own cozy retreat. The showstopper is the stunning addition featuring soaring cathedral ceilings, a cozy fireplace, and windows galore that fill the space with natural light. An attached garage, full basement, and attractive landscaping add even more appeal. Located in the heart of Newcomerstown, within walking distance of the middle/high school and elementary school, this home offers space, character, and convenience for the whole family!

492 S River Street, Newcomerstown
599 E Canal Street, Newcomerstown
$155,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5250112 MLS
This spacious home is located on a corner lot with a nice yard, beautiful trees, a large back deck and 2-car garage. The convenient layout offers a living room, family room, dining room, eat-in kitchen and half bath on the main floor. Three generously sized bedrooms and a full bath make up the second floor while the attic offers plenty of space for storage and has potential to be extra living space. The basement also offers plenty of room for storage and/or hobbies. Interior photos coming Oct 26!

599 E Canal Street, Newcomerstown
24328 Township Road 252b, Newcomerstown
$?
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5253278 MLS
LIVE AUCTION TUESDAY NOV 10TH AT 5:00PM Enjoy peaceful country living with this charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath bungalow situated on 10 acres in the rolling hills of eastern Coshocton County. Offered in 2 parcels, this property provides plenty of opportunities for those looking for a hobby farm, a place to raise animals, or simply a quiet country retreat. The home features approximately 994 square feet of living space and a welcoming porch where you can relax and enjoy the surrounding countryside. Additional features include central air conditioning, an outdoor wood-burning heating system, and a private spring-fed water supply. Outside, you'll find a bank barn, two finished shop buildings 25x35 & 30x40, and additional outbuildings offering ample space for equipment, livestock, hobbies, or workshop activities. A pavilion provides the perfect setting for outdoor gatherings and summer evenings. The gently rolling acreage offers room for gardening, animals, recreation, or simply enjoying the privacy of country living. Parcel 1: Home and outbuildings situated on 5.09± acres with approximately 412 feet of road frontage. Parcel 2: 5± acres of mostly open land with approximately 380 feet of road frontage, offering opportunities for agricultural use, recreation, or a potential building site.

24328 Township Road 252b, Newcomerstown
County Road 106, Newcomerstown
$1,050,000
5254821 MLS
This one is truly special, absolutely breathtaking views that pictures don’t even do justice to. There are so many special options with this property, and the moment you step onto these 91.07 acres on County Road 106 in Newcomerstown, you’ll understand why. Stretching across both sides of the road, this beautiful property offers an incredible mix of expansive pasture, tillable ground, and woods to explore and hunt. Natural springs with livestock watering troughs for livestock add to its character, while the sweeping countryside views make it easy to imagine a different pace of life. Looking for a hunting retreat or a weekend getaway? Dreaming of starting your own homestead, creating a family compound, or finding the perfect setting for your forever home? With numerous potential homesites, there’s room to explore those dreams. You might even envision an Airbnb retreat where guests can experience the scenery and peaceful surroundings. Spend your mornings taking in the views, your afternoons walking the land, and your evenings watching the countryside settle into quiet. Whether your vision includes working the ground, enjoying the outdoors, or building a place to gather for generations, this property deserves a closer look. Located approximately 15 minutes from I-77 and just a short drive into Newcomerstown, you can enjoy a country setting without feeling disconnected. This property is truly fantastic. Come walk it, take in the views, and imagine the possibilities.

County Road 106, Newcomerstown
229 E State Street, Newcomerstown
$185,000
5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5254137 MLS
This duplex is conveniently located close to the grocery stores, banks and schools. The first floor apartment has 3 bedrooms and 1 bathroom and rents for $600 monthly. The top apartment has 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom and rents for $700 monthly. Each has their own laundry area. The garage is 36x32 with all new doors, siding and roof. The garage is rented for $200 a month. Listing agent is a member of the LLC.

229 E State Street, Newcomerstown
373 Cross Street, Newcomerstown
$180,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5253330 MLS
Welcome to 373 Cross Street in Newcomerstown! This charming 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath home showcases timeless character, distinctive details, and a welcoming style all its own. Original built-ins and eclectic wallpaper add personality and vintage appeal throughout. The main-level primary bedroom and full bathroom offer convenient first-floor living, while two additional bedrooms and a half bath are located upstairs. The finished basement family room provides valuable additional living space, perfect for entertaining, relaxing, or gathering with family and friends. Outside, enjoy attractive curb appeal, rear paved parking, and a detached two-car garage. A recorded easement for ingress and egress involving the neighboring property is documented in the public records. With its unique character, functional layout, and desirable garage and parking features, this home offers a distinctive opportunity in Newcomerstown. Don't miss your chance to make this charming property yours! Schedule your private showing today!

373 Cross Street, Newcomerstown
1103 W State Street, Newcomerstown
$185,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5250933 MLS
There’s plenty to love about this charming four-bedroom, two-bath bungalow in Newcomerstown! Enjoy your morning coffee on the covered front porch, then head inside to bright living and dining spaces with beautiful wood trim and plenty of character. The kitchen offers ample cabinet and counter space, and a main-floor bedroom, full bath, and laundry make everyday living convenient. Upstairs, you’ll find the third and fourth bedrooms and another full bath. An attached one-car garage, covered rear porch, and storage shed round out the property. Come take a look and make it your own!

1103 W State Street, Newcomerstown
Kings Ridge Road, Newcomerstown
$1
5248565 MLS
Located near Newcomerstown, check out this beautiful 41+ acre property being offered in two land parcels, as well as two mineral parcels giving buyers the flexibility to purchase one or all and tailor the property to their needs. Each parcel features its own hunting blind and food plot, with access from two directions, making this an excellent opportunity for hunters, recreational buyers, or investors. The property also includes a small cabin, storage shed, and established driveway. Whether you’re looking to secure your own hunting tract, purchase both parcels for a larger recreational property, or invest in land with mineral rights, this auction offers plenty of options. Check it out now!

Kings Ridge Road, Newcomerstown
Kings Ridge Road, Newcomerstown
$1
5248616 MLS
Located near Newcomerstown, Parcel #2 offers 19.83 acres of recreational and hunting land with its own hunting blind and established food plot. This parcel provides a great opportunity for buyers looking for a manageable hunting tract that is ready to enjoy this fall. With convenient access and plenty of room for hunting, recreation, and land management, the property offers a variety of possibilities. Purchase Parcel #2 on its own for your own private getaway, or combine it with Parcel #1 to create a larger 41+ acre recreational property. Whether you’re looking for hunting land, a weekend retreat, or a long-term land investment, this 19.83-acre parcel is worth a look!

Kings Ridge Road, Newcomerstown
Kings Ridge Road, Newcomerstown
$1
5248597 MLS
Located near Newcomerstown, Parcel #1 offers 21.79 acres of recreational and hunting land with the added benefit of an established cabin, storage shed, and driveway. The property features its own hunting blind and food plot, making it a great setup for deer hunting and outdoor recreation. With the cabin already in place, buyers have a convenient base camp for hunting weekends, property management, or simply enjoying time outdoors. Whether you’re looking for your own hunting tract, a recreational getaway, or a land investment, this 21.79-acre parcel offers a great combination of acreage, improvements, and usability. Check it out now!

Kings Ridge Road, Newcomerstown
Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Carol Goff & Associates are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!