Newcomerstown OH Real Estate | Newcomerstown Homes For Sale

?? COMPLETELY REMODELED! 3 BED • 2 BATH • CORNER LOT • 3-CAR GARAGE • BONUS ROOM • NEW ROOF • NEW WINDOWS • NEW HVAC • AND SO MUCH MORE! ?? ?? WOW! Completely Remodeled 3-Bedroom, 2-Bath Home — So Much to Offer! THIS ONE IS A MUST SEE! Beautifully remodeled from top to bottom and sitting on a spacious 50x143 corner lot, this home combines modern updates, flexible living space, and an incredible amount of garage and storage space! Step inside to a bright open-concept living and dining area featuring stylish new flush-mount ceiling lights with a convenient nightlight feature. The spacious kitchen offers plenty of cabinets and comes equipped with a stove, refrigerator, dishwasher, and microwave. The main floor offers a master bedroom, 2 full baths, main-floor laundry, and a bonus room that can be whatever you need — home office, family room, playroom, hobby room, or guest space. Upstairs you'll find 2 additional bedrooms. And the updates? WOW! New standing-seam roof, windows, water heater, furnace, ductwork, central air, plumbing, added insulation, and much more! Outside, you'll have plenty of room for vehicles, hobbies, storage, or a workshop with a 1-car attached garage AND a 2-car detached garage. Improvements currently in process include updated fencing, fresh paint in the master bedroom, and plywood sheeting in the detached garage. ? Remodeled. Spacious. Versatile. Lots of parking. Tons of updates. With the combination of the corner lot, flexible floor plan, updated systems, modern finishes, and three-car garage space, this home offers something you don't find every day. Don't let this one get away — schedule your showing and come see everything this home has to offer!

241 Mckinley Avenue, Newcomerstown

$209,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5242841 MLS

This well-maintained home for sale by auction in Newcomerstown, Ohio, offers more space than its exterior suggests. Situated on a 75' x 200' lot, the home features 1,420 sq. ft. on the main floor, 1,240 sq. ft. in the lower level, three main-floor bedrooms with cedar-lined closets, two full bathrooms, an attached two-stall garage, and a separate 35' x 40' workshop with electric service. The main floor includes a comfortable living room, eat-in kitchen with a wood-burning fireplace, full bathroom with walk-in shower, laundry hookups, and multiple storage closets. A bonus room connecting the kitchen, garage, and exterior entrances could serve as a mudroom, pantry, hobby room, or additional storage area. An enclosed porch with windows and screens provides additional seasonal living space. The partially finished basement expands the home’s possibilities with a recreation, brick mantel with decorative electric-log fireplace, second kitchen with eat-at bar, full bathroom, additional laundry hookups, storage room, and cold-storage space. Additional features include mature landscaping, public sewer, private water, and a separate building currently arranged as a woodworking shop. Conveniently located near Newcomerstown and the I-77/US Route 36 interchange, with Cambridge, New Philadelphia, and Dover all approximately 30 minutes away. Property sells at live public auction subject to the published auction terms and conditions.

6063 E State Road, Newcomerstown

$179,900

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5244451 MLS

This charming 3-bedroom home features an oversized open-concept kitchen with plenty of cabinets, first-floor laundry, and one bedroom conveniently located on the main floor. Situated on almost half an acre, enjoy the spacious backyard, back deck, and inviting front porch—perfect for morning coffee. A 2-car detached garage with loft storage provides plenty of space for vehicles and storage. Call for a private tour today!

14060 Pershing Avenue, Newcomerstown

$169,900

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5243918 MLS

Welcome home! This beautifully maintained 2-bedroom, 1½-bath home offers a fantastic combination of updates, character, and functionality. The gorgeous custom kitchen is sure to impress, while updated electrical and plumbing provide added peace of mind. The furnace and AC are approximately two years old. The finished bonus recreation room in the basement adds even more usable living space and offers plenty of possibilities—it could make a great 3rd bedroom, family room, game room, or the perfect spot to kick back and watch the ball game! Outside, you’ll find a 3-bay garage with a concrete floor and electric, providing plenty of room for vehicles, hobbies, storage, or a workshop. Situated on a corner lot with mature shade trees, the property offers a peaceful outdoor setting. One of the home’s most inviting features is the front sunroom, the perfect place to enjoy your morning coffee, curl up with a good book, or simply relax and enjoy the day.

540 Mulvane Street, Newcomerstown

$799,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5243174 MLS

A home in the country with room to grow! Welcome home to this wonderfully updated country home on nearly 65 acres that is ready for your enjoyment. Free gas to the home is a big plus on this one as well as the list of updates that were done to this home is quite extensive. In 2016 this home had a full remodel including roof, windows, gas furnace, central air, new plumbing and electric and just a complete rebuild! The washer, dryer and new fridge stay with the property as well as this one has a tenant in that is looking to stay thus bringing instant income to this investment. Outside you will find ample room for a garden, room for your livestock, some marketable timber and the seller states that he owns 51% of the mineral rights and they will transfer to the buyer unless otherwise negotiated. A nice barn completes the buildings. As you travel the trails , you will see the ample sign of deer and wildlife. Up on the ridge you can see where plenty of deer have been roaming. A natural spring in the wooded area would be a great fit for a new pond!

75601 Eighth Street, Newcomerstown

$179,900

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5241589 MLS

Welcome to this beautifully remodeled 3-bedroom, 1-bath home offering a move-in-ready opportunity in a convenient Newcomerstown location. Completely remodeled throughout, this home combines modern updates with comfortable living space and is within walking distance to Newcomerstown Local Schools. A new roof was installed in 2025, providing added peace of mind for the new owners. The private, fenced-in backyard creates an ideal space for family gatherings, entertaining, children, or simply enjoying some privacy outdoors. All appliances will convey with the sale, making the transition into your new home even easier. The outdoor shed provides additional versatility with a private office space and ample storage. A unique catio offers an outdoor area for pets and includes convenient access directly into the laundry room. With extensive remodeling, a newer roof, fenced in backyard, additional storage and office space, this home is ready for its next owner. Schedule your showing today with a Licensed Real Estate Agent.

503 Tuscarawas Avenue, Newcomerstown

17881 Horseshoe Bend Road E, Newcomerstown

$539,900

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5238185 MLS

Escape to approximately 30 acres of wooded privacy with a completely remodeled cabin and endless opportunities for recreation. Whether you’re looking for a weekend retreat, hunting property, recreational getaway, or a peaceful place surrounded by nature, this property is ready to enjoy from day one. The cabin offers the comforts you want while still giving you that true getaway experience, with electric service, well water, septic, updated plumbing, on-demand hot water and a wood-burning stove. Extensive improvements include updated insulation, windows, doors, flooring, metal roof, light fixtures and more. Outside is where this property really shines! Explore your own ATV and walking trails, venture through the spring fed ravine, or spend the day hunting and exploring your own land. A trail with a large culvert provides access to the back portion of the property, making even more of the acreage accessible. Additional features include a 12’ x 24’ covered porch, newer 18’ x 18’ Amish-built shed with heavy-duty floor, roll-up garage door and deer-hoist support, gravel driveway, picnic area and plenty of space for outdoor equipment and toys. The property was enrolled in a timber CAUV program in 2024, with the seller indicating timber may be ready for harvest in approximately 3–5 years. Buyer to verify timber value, harvest timing and CAUV requirements. And the location makes it even better. Approximately 15 minutes from Salt Fork State Park, offering boating, fishing, hiking, hunting and miles of outdoor recreation. 30 acres. Remodeled cabin. Trails. Timber. Privacy. Recreation. This is the kind of property where you can unplug, unwind and enjoy everything the outdoors has to offer. DO NOT WALK PEOPERTY WITHOUT PRIOR APPROVAL

17881 Horseshoe Bend Road E, Newcomerstown

$539,900

5237480 MLS

Escape to approximately 30 acres of wooded privacy with a completely remodeled cabin and endless opportunities for recreation. Whether you’re looking for a weekend retreat, hunting property, recreational getaway, or a peaceful place surrounded by nature, this property is ready to enjoy from day one. The cabin offers the comforts you want while still giving you that true getaway experience, with electric service, well water, septic, updated plumbing, on-demand hot water and a wood-burning stove. Extensive improvements include updated insulation, windows, doors, flooring, metal roof, light fixtures and more. Outside is where this property really shines! Explore your own ATV and walking trails, venture through the spring fed ravine, or spend the day hunting and exploring your own land. A trail with a large culvert provides access to the back portion of the property, making even more of the acreage accessible. Additional features include a 12’ x 24’ covered porch, newer 18’ x 18’ Amish-built shed with heavy-duty floor, roll-up garage door and deer-hoist support, gravel driveway, picnic area and plenty of space for outdoor equipment and toys. The property was enrolled in a timber CAUV program in 2024, with the seller indicating timber may be ready for harvest in approximately 3–5 years. Buyer to verify timber value, harvest timing and CAUV requirements. And the location makes it even better. Approximately 15 minutes from Salt Fork State Park, offering boating, fishing, hiking, hunting and miles of outdoor recreation. 30 acres. Remodeled cabin. Trails. Timber. Privacy. Recreation. This is the kind of property where you can unplug, unwind and enjoy everything the outdoors has to offer. DO NOT WALK THE PROPERTY WITHOUT PRIOR APPROVAL

17881 Horseshoe Bend Road E, Newcomerstown

$139,900

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5235284 MLS

Well-maintained duplex offering an excellent opportunity for investors or owner-occupants. One unit is currently tenant occupied, while the second unit is owner occupied, providing flexibility for a future owner. Recent exterior improvements include a brand-new metal roof and newly installed windows, enhancing the property's long-term durability and energy efficiency. Conveniently located in Newcomerstown, this property is close to local schools, parks, shopping, and other everyday amenities. Buyers are encouraged to perform their own due diligence regarding lease terms, rental opportunities, and future use of the property.

440 Center Street, Newcomerstown

$174,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5229000 MLS

Welcome to this charming, move-in ready two-story home situated on a quiet street. Offering 3 bedrooms, 1.5 baths, a first-floor laundry, and a spacious 24' x 28' detached building, this home combines character with modern updates. Step inside to a welcoming open foyer that leads to a spacious living room and formal dining room, both featuring beautiful arched doorways and timeless charm. The fully equipped kitchen includes all of the appliances, making it easy to move right in. A full bath and convenient main-level laundry complete the first floor. Upstairs are three comfortable bedrooms and a half bath. Recent improvements include newer flooring, all new fixtures, pex plumbing, updated electrical, a new front entry door, and a brand-new water softener, providing added value and peace of mind. This is your opportunity to own a well-maintained home with classic character, thoughtful updates, and plenty of extra storage or workspace in the detached 24' x 28' building. Immediate possession is available.

450 Barnett Avenue, Newcomerstown

Newcomerstown Homes for Sale

Your Newcomerstown Real Estate Experts

Map Search

Market Report

Homes For Sale in Newcomerstown

How much is your home worth?

How much is your home worth?

Kurt Ragsdale

Work with an agent you can trust & rely on, for all your Southeast Ohio real estate needs.